“Hunger” by Knut Hamsun (another Nobel Prize winner): Nameless narrator, a fiction writer, has multiple personality, but not from hunger

The translator’s Introduction mentions the protagonist’s symptoms of multiple personality (without using that term):

“…Any reader of Hunger is struck by a number of truly astounding psychological facts: first…The life of the mind is depicted in Hamsun’s first novel as discontinuous. Secondly…a divided psyche: several selves may inhabit one and the same body simultaneously…While the device recalls Dostoyevsky’s treatment of the double, Hamsun uses it in a novel manner. Often, the self-division becomes the occasion for humorous playacting as the hero launches into interior dialogues between one part of his psyche and another…” (1, translator’s Introduction).

But Hunger is mostly about the effect on the mind of actual hunger and starvation. Which might raise the question in some readers’ minds at to whether multiple personality could be caused by an impaired brain.

In one episode manifesting multiple personality, the nameless narrator—search “namelessness,” “nameless narrator,” and “nameless”—says, “…my confused state was running away with me, giving me the craziest ideas, which I obeyed one after the other. No matter how much I kept telling myself that I was behaving like an idiot, it was no use; I made the stupidest faces behind the lady’s back and coughed furiously several times as I walked past her…I vaguely felt that it wasn’t I…However estranged I was from myself in that moment, so completely at the mercy of invisible influences, nothing that was taking place around me escaped my perception…” (1, pp. 12-13). The “invisible influences” were alternate personalities pulling his strings from behind the scenes.

A “confused state” in the sense of a delirium from malnutrition would have impaired his faculty of attention; whereas, at the time of the above episode, his attention was quite good (nothing around him escaped his perception) (and around that time, he was still getting inspired and writing publishable articles). Later on, when his brain was impaired from malnutrition, he had no symptoms of multiple personality.

In short, the writer in this novel shows evidence of multiple personality, but only when he is not starving and his brain is working normally, because multiple personality is an ability and mental feat that requires an intact brain with good powers of concentration and memory. It is not from hunger.

1. Knut Hamsun. Hunger [Norway, 1890]. Translated by Sverre Lyngstad. New York, Penguin Books, 1998.

“With Shuddering Fall” by Joyce Carol Oates: In author’s first novel, 17-year-old protagonist struggles with the question of whether she is crazy

“People thought she was queer in the head. True. Perhaps true…Tears streamed over her cheeks…She did not even know what she was crying about” (1, pp. 52-53). “She could not even understand her emotions, or understand if they were truly hers” (1, p. 189). In multiple personality, the personality who is “out” may experience, and be puzzled by, the emotions of another personality who is behind the scenes.

“…Karen felt that, deep inside, secretly inside her, she was able to think clearly and sanely” (1, p. 69). The personality who is “out” is aware of another personality behind the scenes who is high-functioning.

“Her mind went blank…and she lost her sense of time. She could not have said how long it was since she had left her home…Time had proceeded with gaps she did not try to understand” (1, pp. 82-83). Memory gaps are a cardinal symptom of multiple personality, because some personalities have no memory for the period of time that another personality was “out” and in control. Search “memory gaps,” a major recurring issue.

“Your very being is a puzzle to me, a most delightful puzzle,” another character says to Karen (1, p. 124). People with multiple personality have puzzling inconsistency (due to unrecognized influences from, and switching among, alternate personalities). But, unlike people with psychosis, people with multiple personality may be quite engaging.

“Karen could not hold together the snatches of herself that were revealed to her. She was incomplete, not quite human, a mockery of a person” (1, p. 190). Yes, in multiple personality, any one personality is incomplete. It is all of the person’s personalities, taken as a whole, that compose the complete person.

Karen is psychiatrically hospitalized near the end of the novel, but the psychiatrist, about to send her home, is impressed with the basic soundness of her mind. “So very few people we send out of here—rarely anyone like you, self-cured” (1, p. 307).

At the end, back in her home town and living with her family, Karen states the main theme of Joyce Carol Oates’ first novel: “They know something is wrong with me, that my mind is wrong, put together wrong. Am I to blame for that? Can I help my mind? It is insane to look for meaning in life, and it is insane not to; what am I to do?” (1, p. 329). Keep writing.

1. Joyce Carol Oates. “With Shuddering Fall.” New York, Ecco HarperCollins, 1964, 2018.

Joyce Carol Oates (doctoral dissertation by Mary A. Brett): In seven novels “1987-1995…Oates explores the ‘Multiple personalities [that] inhabit us all.’"

https://ruor.uottawa.ca/handle/10393/8557

I am not the only one to see this in her writing.

Joyce Carol Oates (brief 2013 video): Esteemed fiction writer and university professor says, “I’m not sure that I really have a personality”

Oates is referring to her regular, social personality, as seen by her husband and others. She says that what they see is just a facade, a host personality, which is gone when she is not with them.

But she either does not entirely recall, or chooses not to say, exactly what or who becomes apparent when she is alone, except that it has to do with the inner world of her creative mind, which is what she most enjoys.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gEnROS8bcTI

Search “Oates” to see many very interesting past posts.

Letters Submitted: Reasons for Rejection or Publication

Letters submitted to this site are automatically forwarded to me, so that I may click either “rejection” or “publication.”

REJECTION OF LETTERS

Unverified Public Figures: If a letter appears to be signed by a published author or any other public figure, how do I know that the letter writer is not an imposter? Letters from public figures must either include a relatively easy way for me to verify the writer’s identity or should be resubmitted anonymously.

Therapy sought: If a letter writer seems to seek a personal diagnosis, a therapeutic response, or a professional referral, the letter must be rejected, because this is not a therapy site.

PUBLICATION OF LETTERS

Addresses issues of a post: The letter asks relevant questions, disputes facts or inferences, and/or adds relevant facts and ideas.

Teaches me something: about literature, fiction writing, and/or psychology. There is a lot I don’t know yet.

Name Index

Use Search Box to search them

Kobo Abe

Chinua Achebe
André Aciman

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Edward Albee

Laura Albert

Louisa May Alcott
Christine Alexander

Isabel Allende

Martin Amis

Sherwood Anderson

Nancy C. Andreasen

V. C. Andrews

Maya Angelou

William Archer

John Ashbery

Isaac Asimov

Jami Attenberg

Margaret Atwood

Edward Aubyn

Ashley Audrain

Jane Austen

Paul Auster

Fredrik Backman

Mikhail Bakhtin

Gerbrand Bakker
David Baldacci

James Baldwin

Honoré de Balzac

Steve Bannon

John Banville

Pat Barker
Deirdre Barrett

J.M. Barrie

Elif Batuman

Saul Bellow

Marie Benedict (Heather Terrell)
A. K. Benjamin
Brit Bennett
Lucinda Berry

Thomas E. Bevan
Claire Bien

Imogen Binnie
Eugene L. Bliss

Harold Bloom

Judy Blume

Jorge Luis Borges
Paul Bowles

C. J. Box

Jennifer Finney Boylan

T. C. Boyle

Ray Bradbury

Stephen E. Braude

Bertolt Brecht

Taffy Brodesser-Akner

Charlotte Brontë

Emily Brontë

Anita Brookner

David Brooks

Margaret Wise Brown

Sandra Brown

Elizabeth Barrett Browning

Pearl Buck

Frank Budgen

Mikhail Bulgakov

John Bunyan

James Lee Burke

Anna Burns

Octavia Butler

Samuel Butler

Julia Cameron

Lan Cao

Truman Capote

Orson Scott Card

John le Carré

Alice Carrière

Lewis Carroll

Casanova

Vera Caspary

Willa Cather

Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra
Michael Chabon

Raymond Chandler
Lan Samantha Chang

Mary Chase
Stephen Chbosky

John Cheever

Anton Chekhov

Lee Child

Kate Chopin

Agatha Christie

Connie Chung

Bill Clinton

Hillary Clinton

J. M. Coetzee

Gail Collins

Vivian Conan

Michael Connelly

Joseph Conrad

Frank Conroy

Patricia Cornwell

Michael Cunningham

Rachel Cusk

Roald Dahl

BJ Daniels
Kathryn Davis

Viola Davis

Osamu Dazai

Simone de Beauvoir

Daniel Defoe

J. P. Delaney

Delphine de Vigan

Hernan Diaz

Charles Dickens

Emily Dickinson

Joan Didion

Annie Dillard

E. L. Doctorow

Sarah Domet

Wendy Doniger

Fyodor Dostoevsky
W. E. B. Du Bois

Maureen Dowd

Alexandre Dumas

Alexandre Dumas fils

Daphne du Maurier

George du Maurier

Marguerite Duras

Maeve Duvally

Bob Dylan

Albert Einstein

Umberto Eco

Elisabeth Egan

Jennifer Egan

Maggy Van Eijk

Deborah Eisenberg

George Eliot

T. S. Eliot

Ralph Ellison
Lucy Ellmann

Ashley Elston

Akwaeke Emezi
Hualing Nieh Engle
Paul Engle
Jeffrey Eugenides

Euripides

Janet Evanovich

James Fadiman

Susan Faludi

William Faulkner

Christine Feehan

Elena Ferrante
Jeanne Fery

Sally Field

Henry Fielding

A. J. Finn

Alex Finlay

Sebastian Fitzek

F. Scott Fitzgerald

Gustave Flaubert
Ian Fleming

Théodore Flournoy

Gillian Flynn

Lucy Foley
Ford Madox Ford

Richard Ford

E. M. Forster

Carley Fortune

Jon Fosse

Samuel Fosso
John Fowles

Benjamin Franklin

Jonathan Franzen

Marilyn French

Tana French

Esther Freud

Sigmund Freud

Robert Frost

Patric Gagne PhD

Neil Gaiman

Mary Gaitskill

Lisa Gardner

Bonnie Garmus

Romain Gary
Henry Louis Gates Jr.

Robyn Gigl

Charlotte Perkins Gilman
God

Goethe

Nikolai Gogol

Goh Poh Seng

Arthur Golden

William Golding

William Goldman

Allegra Goodman

Alison Gopnik

Edward Gorey

Robert Gottlieb

Sue Grafton

Winston Graham

Nina de Gramont

Joanne Greenberg

Graham Greene

Andrew Sean Greer

Tom Grimes

Laura Griffin
John Grisham

Jordan Gruber

Guy Gunaratne
George Gurdjieff

Abdulrazak Gurnah

Ian Hacking

Tessa Hadley

Matt Haig

Lisa Halliday

Daniel Halpern

Mohsin Hamid

Charles Hamilton (aka Frank Richards)

Dashiell Hammett
Knut Hamsun

Tom Hanks

Kristin Hannah

Thomas Hardy

Jim Harrison
Joy Harjo

Kamala Harris

Paula Hawkins

Nathaniel Hawthorne

Joseph Heller

Brian Herbert

Frank Herbert

Mick Herron

Ernest Hemingway

Emily Henry

Sarah Hepola

Hermann Hesse

Carl Hiaasen

Patricia Highsmith

Alfred Hitchcock

E.T.A. Hoffmann

James Hogg

Elizabeth Holmes
Sherlock Holmes

Homer
Gail Honeyman

Colleen Hoover
Khaled Hosseini

Ana Huang
Victor Hugo
Zora Neale Hurston

Siri Hustvedt

Aldous Huxley
Henrik Ibsen

John Irving

Kazuo Ishiguro

Jenny Jackson

Lisa Jackson

Michael R. Jackson

Shirley Jackson

Henry James
P. D. James

William James

Leslie Jamison

Pierre Janet
N. K. Jemisin

Joan of Arc

Daisy Johnson

James Joyce

Carl Gustave Jung

Franz Kafka

Frida Kahlo

Mary Karr

Susanna Kaysen

John Keats

Claire Keegan

Ken Kesey

Jonas Hassen Khemiri

Kierkegaard (Soren Kierkegaard)

Stephen King

Barbara Kingsolver

Maxine Hong Kingston

Rudyard Kipling

Adam Kirsch

Katie Kitamura

Richard P. Kluft

John Knowles

Hildur Knútsdóttir

Bessel A. van der Kolk, M.D.

Dean Koontz

Nicole Krauss

Ethan Kross

William Kent Krueger

Milan Kundera

R. O. Kwon.

Jhumpa Lahiri

Nicole Lamy

Stieg Larsson

Victor LaValle
Vicki Laveau-Harvie

John le Carré

Chang-rae Lee

Harper Lee

Legion

Ursula K. Le Guin
Ben Lerner

Doris Lessing

Jonathan Lethem

Tracy Letts
Deborah Levy
Dorothy Otnow Lewis, M.D.

Clarice Lispector

Sue Liston

David Lodge

Selma Lagerlöf

Anita Loos

Ross Macdonald

Machado de Assis

Naguib Mahfouz

Rebecca Makkai

Daniel Mallory

Thomas Mann
Hilary Mantel

Kamala Markandaya

Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Yann Martel

Daniel Mason

W. Somerset Maugham

James McBride 

Cormac McCarthy

Mary McCarthy

Alice McDermott
Ian McEwan
May-May Meijer

Herman Melville

Daphne Merkin

Stephenie Meyer
Alex Michaelides

Fern Michaels

A. A. Milne

Czeslaw Milosz

Vladimir Mirodan

Margaret Mitchell

Katia Mitova

Patrick Modiano

Toni Morrison

Elsa Morante

Ottessa Moshfegh

John Mullan

Paul Murray

Dr. Jerry Mungadze
Alice Munro

Haruki Murakami

Iris Murdoch

Elon Musk

Vladimir Nabokov

V. S. Naipaul

R. K. Narayan

Judith Newman
Celeste Ng

Viet Thanh Nguyen

Thomas Van Nortwick

Ann Oakley

Joyce Carol Oates

Odysseus
Jenny Offill

Michael Ondaatje

Eugene O’Neill
Onno van der Hart

George Orwell
Delia Owens
Helen Oyeyemi

Robert B. Oxnam

Chuck Palahniuk

Orhan Pamuk
Ann Patchett

Katherine Paterson

James Patterson

Pamela Paul

Walker Percy

Fernando Pessoa

Philoctetes

Pablo Picasso

Jodi Picoult

Harold Pinter

Luigi Pirandello

Jayne Anne Phillips

Sylvia Plath

Carole Brooks Platt

Edgar Allan Poe
Richard Powers

Morton Prince

Bill Pronzini
Francine Prose

Marcel Proust

Vladimir Putin

Frank W. Putnam, M. D.

Thomas Pynchon

Ann Radcliffe

Pauline Réage

Taylor Jenkins Reid

Erich Maria Remarque

Ruth Rendell

Jean Rhys

Anne Rice

Samuel Richardson

Nora Roberts

Marilynne Robinson
Fred Rogers

Marius Romme

Sally Rooney

Jeneva Rose

Philip Roth

J.K. Rowling

Arundhati Roy

Benjamin Rush

Salman Rushdie

Richard Russo

Kate Elizabeth Russell

Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

Elyn Saks

Riley Sager

J. D. Salinger

Lucy Sante

Sophie Santos

José Saramago
Vedat Sar

Jean-Paul Sartre

George Saunders

Michel Sauret

Dorothy L. Sayers

Dorothy L. Sayers

Morton Schatzman

John Schu

Philip Schultz

Lucy Score

Sir Walter Scott

Lisa Scottoline

Marguerite Sechehaye

Anne Sexton

Shakespeare

Dani Shapiro

Gail Sheehy

Sidney Sheldon

Mary Shelley

Georges Simenon

Neil Simon

S. E. Hinton
Isaac Bashevis Singer

Karin Slaughter

Christine Smallwood
Jane Smiley

Betty Smith

Helene Smith

Rosamond Smith

Will Smith

Zadie Smith

Socrates

Anna Solomon

Susan Sontag

Sophocles

Muriel Spark

Nicholas Sparks

Herbert Spiegel

Steven Spielberg
Carolyn S. Spiro, M.D.

Danielle Steel
John Steinbeck

Stendhal

Mary Stewart

Robert Louis Stevenson

Bram Stoker

August Strindberg
Elizabeth Strout

Douglas Stuart
John Sutherland

Jonathan Swift

Amy Tan

Donna Tartt

Marjorie Taylor
Tori Telfer

Alfred, Lord Tennyson

Josephine Tey

W. M. Thackeray

Paul Theroux

Brad Thor

Amy Tintera

James Tiptree, Jr.

(Alice B. Sheldon)

Olga Tokarczuk

Colm Tóibin

J.R.R. Tolkien

Leo Tolstoy

P. L. Travers (Mary Poppins)

Helen of Troy

Donald Trump
Mary L. Trump
Laura Turner

Mark Twain

Anne Tyler

Mario Vargas Llosa

Jules Verne

Voltaire

Kurt Vonnegut

Valentine Vox
Warwick Wadlington
Pamela Spiro Wagner
Phoebe Sparrow Wagner

Alice Walker

Herschel Walker

David Foster Wallace

Robert James Waller

Andrea Wang

Jesmyn Ward

Ruth Ware

Robert Penn Warren

Patricia Waugh

Mary Watkins
W. E. B. Du Bois

Fay Weldon
H. G. Wells

Eudora Welty

Tara Westover

Edith Wharton

E. B. White

Patrick White

Colson Whitehead

Walt Whitman

Oscar Wilde
John Williams

Katie Williams

Tennessee Williams

Thomas Williams

Edmund Wilson

Jacqueline Winspear

Kevin Wilson

Jeanette Winterson

Cherise Wolas

James Wood

Sue Woolfe

Virginia Woolf

William Wordsworth
Herman Wouk
Richard Wright

Rebecca Yarros

W. B. Yeats

Matthew Zapruder

Gabrielle Zevin