BASIC CONCEPTS

— When novelists claim they do not invent it, but hear voices and find stories in their head, they are neither joking nor crazy.

— When characters, narrators, or muses have minds of their own and occasionally take over, they are alternate personalities.

— Alternate personalities and memory gaps, but no significant distress or dysfunction, is a normal version of multiple personality.

— normal Multiple Personality Trait (MPT) (core of Multiple Identity Literary Theory), not clinical Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD)

— The normal version of multiple personality is an asset in fiction writing when some alternate personalities are storytellers.

— Multiple personality originates when imaginative children with normal brains have unassuaged trauma as victim or witness.

— Psychiatrists, whose standard mental status exam fails to ask about memory gaps, think they never see multiple personality.

— They need the clue of memory gaps, because alternate personalities don’t acknowledge their presence until their cover is blown.

— In novels, most multiple personality, per se, is unnoticed, unintentional, and reflects the author’s view of ordinary psychology.

— Multiple personality means one person who has more than one identity and memory bank, not psychosis or possession.

— Euphemisms for alternate personalities include parts, pseudonyms, alter egos, doubles, double consciousness, voice or voices.

— Multiple personality trait: 90% of fiction writers; possibly 30% of public.

— Each time you visit, search "name index" or "subject index," choose another name or subject, and search it.

— If you read only recent posts, you miss most of what this site has to offer.

— Share site with friends.

MPD Textbooks: — Frank W. Putnam, MD. Diagnosis and Treatment of Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) (a.k.a. Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), New York, The Guilford Press, 1989. —James G. Friesen, PhD. Uncovering the Mystery of MPD, (includes discussion of demonic possession) Eugene, Oregon, Wipf and Stock Publishers,1997.

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Charles Dickens’s Miss Twinkleton, Another Character with Gratuitous Multiple Personality

The previous post reminded me of a character in Dickens’s The Mystery of Edwin Drood:

“As, in some cases of drunkenness, and in others of animal magnetism [hypnosis], there are two states of consciousness which never clash, but each of which pursues its separate course as though it were continuous instead of broken (thus, if I hide my watch when I am drunk, I must be drunk again before I can remember where), so Miss Twinkleton has two distinct and separate phases of being. Every night, the moment the young ladies [at the boarding school] have retired to rest, does Miss Twinkleton smarten up her curls a little, brighten up her eyes a little, and become sprightly Miss Twinkleton whom the young ladies have never seen. Every night, at the same hour, does Miss Twinkleton resume the topics of the previous night…whereof Miss Twinkleton, in her scholastic state of existence, is as ignorant as a granite pillar.”

Dickens’s description, which includes amnesia between the two personalities, is a more definitive description of multiple personality, but Grafton’s is quite sufficient.

In regard to the cases of alcohol and hypnosis, I would disagree with Dickens that those are different. Drugs and hypnosis can facilitate the switching among personalities in multiple personality.

However, my main point is that, as with Grafton’s character, Dickens’s giving multiple personality to Miss Twinkleton is gratuitous.

It is just that both Dickens and Grafton see multiple personality as common enough so that you really don’t need a special reason for a character to have it.
Why does Sue Grafton gratuitously suggest that a character in S is for Silence might have multiple personality?

After my recent posts about Sue Grafton, I decided to read one of her novels, which I had not done for many years. So I just read S is for Silence (2005), which I had never read.

Tom Padgett is described as a man who, with his wife Cora out of town, “was an entirely different man. It was like having a separate personality, one he called forth and wore like a smoking jacket while she was gone. He had two such personalities, as a matter of fact. When he drank, especially at the Blue Moon, he relaxed into the blue-collar type from which he sprang. He was a good old boy at heart. He liked his boots and jeans, adding a western-cut sport coat when he felt like dressing up. Here in Cora’s fancy house, sober and unobserved, he activated another side of his nature, playing the Lord of the Manor. He was jaunty and dapper. He used a cigarette holder when he smoked and affected a snooty accent when he talked to himself.”

The information that this character has more than one personality is neither a clue nor a red herring in this mystery novel. It is gratuitous. There is no reason for its inclusion.

When a novel includes multiple personality for no literary reason, I think the reason is that the author takes multiple personality for granted. It is simply how people are, in that author’s personal experience.

Monday, February 10, 2014

William Faulkner, in various Interviews, describes the Nature of Characters and the Process of Writing

“You can have no more control over [a character] than you would an incorrigible child.”

When Faulkner was asked how he chose such unusual but appropriate names for his characters, he replied that he did not name them: “They tell me their names.” What about the character in Pylon who does not have a name: “He never did tell me his name.”

Q: When you first begin to write a story, do you have a sort of an outline in your mind…?
A: I would say it develops itself. It begins with a character, usually, and once he stands up on his feet and begins to move, all I do is to trot along behind him with a paper and pencil trying to keep up long enough to put down what he says and does, that he is taking charge of it. I have very little to do except the policeman in the back of the head which insists on unity and coherence and emphasis in telling it. But the characters themselves, they do what they do, not me.

Conversations with William Faulkner. Edited by M. Thomas Inge. Jackson, University Press of Mississippi, 1999
The Sound and the Fury: William Faulkner’s Rashomon, written by four or five Alternate Personalities

In the same Paris Review interview discussed in yesterday’s post, Faulkner tells how The Sound and the Fury was written.

The novel’s first narrator was “the idiot child.” The second narrator was “another brother.” The third narrator was “the third brother.” The fourth narrator was the interviewee, “making myself the spokesman.” The latter says he made a fifth attempt to tell the story fifteen years later in an appendix to another book. “I couldn’t leave it alone, and I never could tell it right, though I tried hard and would like to try again, though I’d probably fail again.”

According to Faulkner, telling the story from those four or five points of view was not an innovative technique. It represented his five attempts to tell the story right, which, according to Faulkner, never succeeded.

Objectively, Faulkner did make five attempts to tell the story. But that is not what happened in Faulkner’s subjective experience of it. Because each narrator noted above was an autonomous alternate personality with, in Faulkner’s subjective experience, a mind of its own.

On the page just before he tells how he wrote The Sound and the Fury, Faulkner says the kind of thing that so many novelists acknowledge: “Because with me there is always a point in the book where the characters themselves rise up and take charge and finish the job…”

That is how novels are written. Novelists keep saying so. But nobody believes them.

So The Sound and the Fury was actually written in the way I speculated in previous posts that the Japanese tale—made into the movie Rashomon—was written.

I suspect that a lot of what has been thought of as modern and postmodern literary innovations could be better explained by Multiple Identity Literary Theory.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

William Faulkner, lacking a good Host Personality, inadvertently implies that he has Multiple Personality

Faulkner’s interview by Jean Stein in Paris Review (New York City, 1956) begins as follows:

INTERVIEWER: Mr. Faulkner, you were saying a while ago that you don’t like being interviewed.

WILLIAM FAULKNER: The reason I don’t like interviews is that I seem to react violently to personal questions. If the questions are about the work, I try to answer them. When they are about me, I may answer or I may not, but even if I do, if the same question is asked tomorrow, the answer may be different.

Most people would take the above to mean that since Faulkner likes his personal privacy, he will not cooperate with questions that invade his personal privacy, and so he will either refuse to answer such questions or he will give unreliable answers out of spite.

On the second and third pages of the interview, asked how a writer becomes a serious novelist, he says the following:

FAULKNER: …An artist is a creature driven by demons. He doesn’t know why they choose him and he’s usually too busy to wonder why. He is completely amoral in that he will rob, borrow, beg, or steal from anybody and everybody to get the work done…If a writer has to rob his mother he will not hesitate; the “Ode on a Grecian Urn” is worth any number of old ladies.

Most people would take this to mean that Faulkner is totally dedicated to his writing, as any serious writer would be. But he seems to be in an obnoxious, irritable mood.

I would interpret the above differently. “If the same [personal] question is asked tomorrow, the answer may be different” because you may be talking to a different personality.

Regarding “An artist is a creature driven by demons,” we should keep in mind that Faulkner had continued to read the Bible since childhood. And when they say “demons” in the Bible, they don’t mean it as a metaphor for being determined or irritable, they mean being possessed, which psychiatry now understands to be multiple personality.

Why does Faulkner have such problems with interviews, in contrast to other writers like Doris Lessing, Sue Grafton, and Mark Twain? If you look at videos of interviews with Lessing or Grafton, they are pleasant, polished, and consistent. If you read interviews with Twain, he was similar. My answer is that, with those three, the interviewer would be speaking to their host personality (discussed in previous posts), a kind of personality that Faulkner evidently lacked.

Friday, February 7, 2014

Twenty-Eight Highlights and Brief Notes

1. The idea that novelists have a split personality (multiple personality) has been suspected in the literary community for at least 150 years, said Margaret Atwood.
2. The split personality of Charles Dickens was first pointed out in 1939/41 by Edmund Wilson.
3. The split personality of Mark Twain was first pointed out in 1920 by Van Wyck Brooks.
4. Posts on Dickens and Twain support this with additional facts.
5. Multiple personality in novelists, which they use in their writing process, has been generally ignored by psychologists who study creativity, by literature professors and literary theory, and by psychiatry (which is interested only in multiple personality disorder and does not recognize normal multiple personality).
6. Freud, who himself probably had multiple personality, neither discovered nor understood the unconscious, which, anyway, doesn’t exist. What Freud called “the unconscious” is really multiple consciousness (with one consciousness unaware of what the other consciousness is thinking.)
7. The practical difference between these two views is that people who think in terms of the unconscious cannot understand how multiple personality could possibly exist. But even Freud grudgingly acknowledged that it does exist. 
8. And since psychoanalytic literary theory derives from the mistaken “unconscious” perspective, it is antithetical to multiple identity literary theory, which is newly proposed in this blog.
9. Since being “possessed” has now been recognized to be multiple personality disorder by the official psychiatric diagnostic manual (DSM-5), it is clear that multiple personality disorder has been known since Biblical times (making it one of the oldest and most established psychiatric disorders) and that Jesus may have been its first therapist (Mark 5:1-20).
10. Normal religious experience may be based on dual consciousness (William James), which is the psychological foundation and simplest form of normal multiple personality.
11. Novelists commonly acknowledge that they experience their characters as having minds of their own. This subjective experience of having more than one personified, independent-minded, psychological entity is the essence of multiple personality.
12. Normal multiple personality—in contrast to the mental disorder, and by virtue of its having more cooperation among the identities—does not cause the person serious distress or dysfunction; indeed, it may be an asset (e.g., to write novels).
13. Dissociative identity disorder (multiple personality disorder, the mental illness) is present in 1.5% of the general population (according to DSM-5), which would make it twice as common as schizophrenia. And although you sometimes hear multiple personality referred to as a “controversial diagnosis,” it is actually more specific and clearly defined than schizophrenia.
14. Normal multiple personality is present in up to 30% of the general public and 90% of novelists (these figures are educated guesses).
15. In the psychiatric diagnostic manual, DSM-5, dissociative identity disorder is in the chapter on Dissociative Disorders, which are not psychotic. Schizophrenia, a psychosis, is in a different chapter and is in a completely different diagnostic category.
16. Dissociative identity disorder (aka multiple personality disorder) is considered to be mainly a psychological disorder—originating in childhood as a way to cope with trauma—and is treated with specific psychotherapy. In contrast, schizophrenia is considered to be mainly a biological disorder whose primary treatment is medication.
17.  Multiple personality is usually hidden and camouflaged. Often the only clues that a person might have it are that they have a puzzling inconsistency (because, without your realizing it, you are meeting, or seeing the effects of, different personalities) and memory gaps (when one personality has no memory of what another personality did). Moreover, you are mostly meeting the “host personality,” who may know very little about the other personalities. (See also Henry James and Doris Lessing, below, about the host personality.) However, once it is diagnosed or recognized, and the personalities see that hiding is futile and you are no threat, they may become quite overt and you can speak with each of them.
18.  In literary criticism, the term alter ego is used in two ways. First, if the author is writing a philosophical novel with a character who is expressing the author’s philosophical views, that character may be referred to as the author’s alter ego, in the sense of being the author’s spokesperson. Second, if the author has a character who has certain superficial similarities to the author, and, perhaps, is a recurring character in that author’s novels, that character may also be referred to as the author’s alter ego. But in this latter case, alter ego is a euphemism for a character who is an alternate personality with a mind of its own. Examples of the latter would be Philip Roth’s Nathan Zuckerman and Sue Grafton’s Kinsey Millhone.
19.  Toni Morrison and Stephen King illustrate the same three basic components of the process of writing novels: First, alter one’s state of consciousness. Second, experience autonomous characters (alternate personalities) coming forward. Third, control and prune the characters.
20.  Rashomon may have originated when the author decided not to control or prune the characters (alternate personalities), but rather to let them each tell the story from their own perspective.
21. The post “Who Wrote Toni Morrison’s Jazz” discusses that it is not just the characters who may be alternate personalities. The narrator may be an alternate personality.
22. Indeed, when an alternate personality not only wants to take over the narration, but wants to publish on its own, this may take the form of an author’s publishing under a pseudonym.
23. Joseph Conrad’s “The Secret Sharer” is a short story about how multiple personality is used to write fiction.
24. Henry James’s “The Turn of the Screw” is not ambiguous. It is inconsistent, probably due to multiple narrator personalities who didn’t get their act together.
25. Henry James’s “The Private Life” is about multiple personality’s “host personality.”
26. Doris Lessing, in her autobiography, said that among her personalities was a “Hostess.”
27. Sue Grafton’s Kinsey and Me (2013), according to what Grafton stated in an interview, reveals that she has “several personalities.”
28. A post on J. M. Barrie’s Peter Pan pointed out that the story of a boy “who never grows up” is not about immaturity, but about multiple personality, since people with multiple personality usually have one or more child-aged alternate personalities who never grow up. And especially since NBC television in the USA has plans for a live broadcast of Peter Pan this coming Christmas holiday season, I expect to discuss Barrie further, including his writer alternate personality, whom Barrie called “McConnachie.”

Thursday, February 6, 2014

Sue Grafton Experiences “Kinsey Millhone” and “Kit Blue” as Persons, Not Just Characters

Since Kinsey Millhone and Kit Blue exist only in the writings of Sue Grafton, readers jump to the conclusion that Grafton experiences them as being only invented characters. Grafton certainly knows that they are invented characters, but that doesn’t mean she experiences them as such.

I know this from what Grafton says in her book Kinsey and Me (2013), mentioned in my two previous posts. To understand what Grafton means, you have to assume that she is good at expressing herself with the written word, and then you have to read what she actually wrote.

Grafton says, “Kinsey Millhone entered my life, like an apparition, sometime in 1977.” That means Grafton saw Kinsey as a visual hallucination or vision. “Often I feel she’s peering over my shoulder, whispering, nudging me, making bawdy remarks.” That means Grafton also hears the voice and feels the touch of Kinsey. Of course, Grafton knows this is her imagination and that she invented Kinsey, but Grafton’s imagination is so vivid that she sees, hears, and feels Kinsey, and experiences Kinsey as a thinking being with a mind of her own.

Grafton says, “Kit Blue is simply a younger version of me.” That is not exactly the same as saying that Kit Blue is Grafton when she was younger. If the latter were the case, Grafton could, should, and would have replaced the fictitious name with her own name in the current tell-how-it-really-was publication. There is no reason to retain the Kit Blue name unless Grafton experiences Kit Blue as a person distinct from herself: as an alternate personality of a younger age than Grafton.

Grafton wrote Kinsey and Me to say what she did say, explicitly, in the television interview: “I have several personalities.” Which would make her like Dickens, Twain, etc., except that Grafton has had more best sellers.

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Sue Grafton Discusses her “Shadow” (secret sharer, subconscious, imaginary companion, alternate personality) in Three other Interviews

In my last post about an interview for her book Kinsey and Me (2013), Sue Grafton mentioned “Shadow” as being one of her “several personalities.” Looking through a few of Grafton’s past interviews, I find it may be new that she is framing the issue in terms of multiple personality, but she has been mentioning Shadow for more than fifteen years.

She says that she got the term “shadow” from a Jungian therapist whom she had seen for writer’s block. The Jungian therapist said that she should listen to her unconscious, her “shadow,” for creative insight. Since then, Grafton says that she loves writer’s block, because it’s a message from her unconscious, her shadow, about what to do with the story she is writing.

However, what she now refers to as her Shadow—a nice, publicly acceptable term, since, according to Jungians, everybody has one—actually originated in her childhood as a sort of imaginary companion. “I guess that’s where Shadow comes from. I’ve been having a constant conversation with my dark side for most of my life.”

So Shadow is a personified psychological entity whom Grafton has been having conversations with since childhood. It seems to be a friendly, constructive relationship, but Shadow can be quite critical and arrogant, evidently due to superior knowledge. Grafton quotes Shadow as once saying to her, “Oh sweetie, you don’t have the foggiest idea what this book is about.”

A key feature of Grafton’s writing process is that she keeps a long and detailed journal of her thoughts about the book she is writing. One purpose of the journal is that it serves as a medium of communication between Grafton and Shadow. “I leave her notes in my journal, you know. ‘Dear, dear Shadow, please help me. Your friend, Sue.’” Sometimes the questions and answers are quite specific to the characters and plot of the book she is writing.

Grafton says, “I try not to create so much as I discover. One of my theories about these books is that they already exist.” She attributes this attitude to her religious background and the Presbyterian belief in predestination. But the idea that her books already exist and that she just has to discover them would also seem to be implied by the way her books seem to be already known to, and provided by, Shadow.

Monday, February 3, 2014

Sue Grafton, bestselling novelist, says, “I have several personalities” including “The Shadow, who does the work…”

Sue Grafton is the author of a series of bestselling novels featuring private detective Kinsey Millhone. The title of each book starts with a letter of the alphabet, and it won’t be long before Grafton has published her 26th bestseller.

In 2013, Grafton published Kinsey and Me, half of which is a collection of short stories featuring her alter ego Kinsey Millhone, and half of which is a series of autobiographical reminiscences in which she calls herself “Kit Blue” and describes episodes in her difficult childhood.

I recall that a number of years ago I read an interview online in which Grafton told the interviewer that sometimes she and Kinsey disagree about how the plot of a novel should go. Kinsey wants it to go one way and Grafton wants it to go another way. So, Grafton said, “You’ll think I’m crazy,” but Grafton will stop writing, leave the computer, and come back later “when Kinsey is not around,” so Grafton can write it her way. So when I recently heard of the publication of Kinsey and Me, I got it, in the hope that Grafton would elaborate.

Well, the book does not elaborate on Grafton’s relationship with Kinsey. And the part of the book featuring “Kit Blue” will just be puzzling to most readers.

So I found a public television video in which Grafton is interviewed about Kinsey and Me.


In the interview, you will see and hear Grafton say the things I quote in the title of this post (if you don't blink, it is so brief). And she wouldn’t have published Kinsey and Me and then said, publicly, what I quote, if she hadn’t wanted to discuss her “several personalities.” But when novelists bring up this subject, interviewers never pursue it.

Sunday, February 2, 2014

Rashomon Postscript: Wasn’t That “Multiple Identity” Interpretation Arbitrary and Silly?

Since Rashoman, the movie, there have been many derivative works for cinema and television, and the whole idea is well known. See Wikipedia, the “Rashomon Effect.” And these derivative works may have been written with the conscious plan of doing a Rashomon plot.

As for the original Japanese tale from the 12th century, I have no information about its author or how it was written. So, as long as any interpretation of the original story is just speculation, why not think of something more likely, such as that it was based on a real event or that the author, a keen observer, had noted that people sometimes don’t tell the truth?

You are right. I have no real basis for my interpretation. It was pure speculation. Except that, based on my discussions of other writers in this blog, I think that that is the way that many original works of fiction are written.

As Mark Twain said, he never created a character in his whole life. His characters started from someone he had known or read about, and then they took on a life of their own. For Toni Morrison, they come from a magical place in her mind, with stories and minds of their own, and then she may or may not control them. And Charles Dickens, as described in the June 2013 post, would watch and listen to his characters tell their tales, and he would write it down (subject, of course, to revision).

So I think it’s reasonable to speculate that the author of the original Rashomon tale got his or her characters the way that Twain, Morrison, and Dickens have, but decided, instead of controlling or pruning them, to let them have their own say, even if it stretched credulity to believe that witnesses would ever differ as much as they did in that story.
Rashomon: An Akira Kurosawa Movie, Based on a Ryunosuke Akutagawa Short Story, Based on a 12th Century Japanese Tale, in Terms of Multiple Identity Literary Theory

The title of the short story, “In a Bamboo Grove,” tells where the rape and murder took place. The story consists of testimony by the various eyewitnesses. Since each eyewitness tells a very different story, the word “rashomon” is now used to mean that different people have different perspectives and that eyewitness testimony may be unreliable.

However, “rashomon” may have another meaning if we interpret the story in terms of Multiple Identity Literary Theory (discussed previously in this blog). According to this theory, the process of fiction writing involves the interaction of autonomous narrator and character identities.

Recall the posts in which I quoted how Toni Morrison and Stephen King controlled and pruned their independent-minded character-personalities. They had to control and prune them in order to keep everything consistent with the story that the narrator wanted to tell.

But what would happen if an author did not control or prune what the narrators and characters wanted to do or say? Suppose each identity were allowed to tell the story the way he or she wanted. Well, the result would be Rashomon.

Let me apply this meaning of “rashomon” to Henry James’s “The Turn of the Screw.” Recall that in my post about that story, I concluded that it was not ambiguous, but rather was inconsistent, because it was written from more than one voice or perspective, which had not been controlled or pruned. If I wanted to review or critique that story using just one word, I could say: rashomon.

Saturday, February 1, 2014

Postscript About the ISSTD and Readers of This Blog

In my post earlier today, I hope that I didn’t come across as too negative about the ISSTD. After all, I used to be a member, myself, when I first became interested in multiple personality. Indeed, for years, I was very active in their local branch. And as far as I know, they are still a fine organization.

You might want to visit the ISSTD website for information or just out of curiosity.

Members of the ISSTD, especially those who read or write novels, you are welcome here.

Professors of literature, you should not feel intimidated by this blog. Learning about multiple personality is not beyond you. Most of what you need to know is in this blog. Just begin with Dickens in the post of June 2013.

And readers, you don’t have to be a professor of any sort to be welcome here. You just have to like novels or write novels and be interested in how it is done. Of course, you novelists already know how you, personally, use multiple personality to write, but you might be interested to read how other novelists have used multiple personality, too.
Why Members of the International Society for the Study of Trauma and Dissociation (ISSTD)—Multiple Personality Experts—Avoid This Blog

The ISSTD is the principal organization for mental health professionals who treat and study dissociative identity disorder (multiple personality disorder). Its members do not read this blog, because this blog is about normal multiple personality, which is not a psychiatric disorder. Dissociative identity disorder is in the psychiatric diagnostic manual (DSM-5); normal multiple personality is not. So this blog is beyond their scope.

If members of the ISSTD ever did see this blog, I think they would take a dim view of it. For any talk of normal multiple personality would remind them of one of the favorite attacks of skeptics. Skeptics like to derisively say that, in a sense, everyone has multiple personality: the psychiatric disorder is just a foolish, gullible, mistaken reification of normal psychology. And ISSTD members would not want to admit that anything the skeptics say is even half right.

Now, the skeptics are wrong about multiple personality disorder. This disorder is actually one of the oldest, most clearly defined, best proven disorders in the diagnostic manual. And it is certainly not true that everyone has multiple personality. Nevertheless, it is true that a substantial minority of the general public does have what I call normal multiple personality: a version of multiple personality that 1. is too common to call an illness, 2. does not cause significant distress or dysfunction, and 3. may be an asset (e.g., in writing novels).

So while most professors of literature avoid this blog—they think it’s preposterous and, anyway, beyond their expertise—most of those mental health professionals who do have expertise with multiple personality disorder avoid this blog, too. They would fear that it could inadvertently support the skeptics. And besides, most multiple personality experts have never studied literature in this regard, and so they, like the literature professors, would see this interdisciplinary blog as going beyond their scope.

Which leaves me with a very select readership.

I wouldn’t want to exaggerate how select. You are not alone. This blog is read by people from more than thirty countries. But in absolute numbers of serious readers? How many people in this whole world are as open-minded and perceptive as you?

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Writer’s Block: Is it Real? What is Being Blocked? Why Couldn’t George Bernard Shaw write a Great Novel? Why Do Some Novelists Drink?

What prompts this post is that writer’s block was mentioned in the last post (as being a specialty of Doris Lessing’s therapist, even though Lessing, herself, did not have it).

Judging by most books published about how to write a novel, you would think that writer’s block is impossible. They tell you what it takes to make good characters, plots, sentences, etc. What is there to get blocked? Nothing. It is all very rational, and if you don’t carry it out and produce a good novel, then you have not followed their advice or are a procrastinator.

So why was Nobel Prize winning playwright George Bernard Shaw a failure as a novelist? He tried it, decided he was not very good at it, and gave up. Evidently, you can be one of the greatest writers who ever lived, but still not have what it takes to be a successful novelist.

And why do some writers feel that they have to drink to tap their creativity? After all, the brain really doesn’t function as well when it is intoxicated.

This all makes sense according to Multiple Identity Literary Theory. What gets blocked in at least one form of writer’s block is access to, and/or the cooperation of, the writer’s alternate personalities. Some novelists use alcohol as a way to sedate their host personality and allow their other personalities to come forward. (Writers like Stephen King and Toni Morrison do not need alcohol, because they know how to access the world of their alternate personalities by using a form of self-hypnosis.) And if you don’t have multiple personality—perhaps that was Shaw’s problem—you might have superb writing skills, but still not be very good at writing novels.

Monday, January 27, 2014

Doris Lessing’s Multiple Personality: Already Known, but Unrecognized, Prior to Multiple Identity Literary Theory

Anyone who has read this month’s posts in their entirety knows not only that Doris Lessing had multiple personality, but that some of her family, friends, readers, scholars, and even the Nobel Prize committee must have already known this, too.

That is, they knew it, but they didn’t know that they knew it, because they had a false image of what multiple personality is like.

The false image of multiple personality (as previously discussed in this blog) is that:
1. it is extremely rare (actually, the normal version is relatively common),
2. it is usually overt (it is usually hidden and camouflaged), and
3. it is psychotic (it is not, and it’s normal version is compatible with a very high level of function; in fact, it is integral to the process of writing novels).

Multiple identity literary theory, as proposed and presented in this blog, is not encompassed by any other literary theory. In particular, it is not an extension of psychoanalytic literary theory. As previously discussed, multiple identity literary theory and psychoanalytic literary theory are antithetical, because they derive from rival and contradictory models of the mind.

A psychoanalytically-oriented therapist, per se, would be likely to miss a client’s multiple personality. This is illustrated in the life of Doris Lessing.

In Volume Two of Lessing’s autobiography, Lessing reports that she went to a psychoanalytically-oriented therapist, a “Mrs. Sussman (Mother Sugar in The Golden Notebook), because if I didn’t get some help, I would not survive. These days, everyone goes to a therapist, or is a therapist, but then no one did…And particularly communists did not go ‘into analysis’, for it was ‘reactionary’ by definition…I was so desperate I went. I went two or three times a week, for about three years. I think it saved me…Mrs. Sussman specialized in unblocking artists who were blocked, could not write or paint or compose. This is what she saw as her mission in life. But I did not suffer from a ‘block’. She wanted to discuss my work. I did not want to. I did not see the need for it. So she was perpetually frustrated, bringing up the subject, while I deflected her. Mrs. Sussman…gave me what I needed, which was support. Mostly support against my mother [who wanted to come and live with her].”

Mrs. Sussman was very helpful to Lessing, but as a psychoanalytically-oriented therapist, per se, she apparently never asked any questions that would have brought out the history of Tigger, etc. It was not something that she would have thought of or considered.

This is no insult or disparagement of Mrs. Sussman. I know from my own experience as a psychiatrist that prior to the time I learned about multiple personality—after I had been a psychiatrist for twelve years—I had been seeing some multiple personality patients literally for years without realizing it.

Sunday, January 26, 2014

Nobel Prize winner Doris Lessing’s “Hostess personality,” Described in Her Autobiography as the most overt Alternate Personality of her Multiple Personality

I quote from Volume One of Doris Lessing’s autobiography:

“I once thought of writing a book called My Alternate Lives…As in those cases of multiple personalities, where only slowly do the personalities inside a woman or man become aware of each other, the heroine of this book — me for argument’s sake — would slowly come to know that multiples of herself are living these other lives.”

“…the personality I call the Hostess…This Hostess personality, bright, helpful, attentive, receptive to what is expected, is very strong indeed. It is a protection, a shield, for the private self. How useful it has been, is now [1994], when being interviewed, photographed, a public person for public use. But behind all that friendly helpfulness was something else, the observer…never to be touched, tasted, felt, seen, by anyone else.”

At age 7, she adopted the name of the A. A. Milne character, Tigger, for one aspect of her hostess personality: “I was the fat and bouncy Tigger. I remained Tigger until I left Rhodesia…This personality was expected to be brash, jokey, clumsy, and always ready to be a good sport, that is, to laugh at herself, apologize, clown, confess inability. An extrovert. In that it was a protection for the person I really was, ‘Tigger’ was an aspect of the Hostess.”

“It was also Tigger who ran away, and joked about it afterwards.”

“How funny that hellfire nun became, when Tigger described her.”

“‘Tigger’ was in control, and I clowned and was pert and ‘clever’…”

“…the sad little girl who lived well hidden by the mask of ‘Tigger’…”

“It was ‘Tigger’ who saw me through…”

“For one term this teacher taught English Literature, and I wrote an essay, or rather ‘Tigger’ did — about her methods of teaching.”

“I was so afraid, and oh how Tigger jested.”

“I wrote a poem. [Poem quoted]. These verses are not here for their worth: they interest me. First, the writer was a fourteen year-old girl…but wait, that cannot be true. Some Ancient had moved in, taken temporary possession of that many-tenanted young mind. Then, it is he who takes moonpaths, he goes adventuring…I did not believe in the efficacy of the spell or rune…The poem comes from a different level of knowledge…” [Persons with multiple personality may have personalities who are of a different age or sex than the person.]

“I could truthfully say that I spent my adolescence in a sexual trance…But this is what I say when in that part of my mind marked Love. I could with equal truth say I spent my childhood, girlhood and youth in the world of books. Or, wandering about in the bush [in Africa], listening, and watching what went on. You remember with what you are at the time you are remembering.” [In multiple personality, different personalities may have different memory banks, so that what the person remembers depends on which personality is in control and doing the remembering at that moment.]

“That year 1937 is described by me according to what memory-mode I am.”

“Recently I met a woman [who had replaced Lessing at a job when Lessing had left to get married. According to this woman, Lessing had been] a quiet and thoughtful person…I was glad to hear this, for what I remember is the chatty brightness of ‘Tigger’ — who was certainly the person who dealt with the social life that at once swept me away into drinking and dancing.” [This other woman had evidently known Lessing from a situation in which one of Lessing’s introverted personalities, and not her extroverted Tigger personality, was in control.]

“In the wedding photographs I look a jolly young matron. It was ‘Tigger’ who was getting married.”

[Some of Lessing’s other personalities were not cheerful like Tigger.] “This feeling of doom, of fatality, is a theme — perhaps the main one — in [my novel] Martha Quest. It was what had made me, and from my earliest childhood, repeat and repeat, ‘I will not, I simply will not.’"

“There were other activities. One was the sale of the Communist newspaper from Cape Town…At one point I was selling 112 dozen copies every week…Comrade Tigger was after all an attractive young woman.”

NOTE: All the above is from Volume One of Lessing’s autobiography, which was published in 1994 and covered years 1919 to 1949. Volume Two, published in 1997, covered 1949 to 1962, the year she published The Golden Notebook. Lessing (1919—2013) did not publish any further autobiography.

Each of the two volumes is about 400 pages. Why not publish one book of 800 pages? To make more money on two books than one? Because there was a natural division between her African years and her London years? Also because different personalities wrote each volume.

The Hostess personality — whether in its Tigger aspect or another aspect — is not even mentioned in Volume Two. Volume Two discusses The Golden Notebook, but nothing about multiple personality (see previous posts this month) is mentioned. The issue of compartmentalization is barely mentioned.

And we know that multiple personality, by whatever name, was an ongoing issue for Lessing even after she moved to London. As Carole Klein’s biography (2000) of Lessing notes: “In Landlocked [1965], volume four of Children of Violence, Martha Quest, tormented by her feelings of division, thinks of herself as a house with half a dozen rooms, an analogy Lessing has often made about her own personality. Martha saw each room in the house as full of people who did not really connect to the people in the other rooms, but only to her.”

Incidentally, we have evidence that people who knew Lessing well could tell when her Tigger personality was out and in control. As noted in the Klein biography, according to recollections obtained from witnesses by Lessing scholar Dee Seligman: When Lessing’s first son, John, six years old at the time, was visiting Lessing at the office, he headed for his mother’s desk, where she was typing, and said to her, “Hello, Tigger. How are you? I haven’t seen you for a while.”

So how can we account for the fact that this prominent issue in Volume One — which we know from her writing was an ongoing issue for Lessing — was completely ignored in Volume Two of her autobiography. Evidently, the teams of writing personalities who worked on Volume One and Volume Two were not the same. If it were only that she decided it was an embarrassing issue that she did not wish to pursue, she could have brushed it off in Volume Two with some brief mention. But the writing team for Volume Two was apparently unaware of the issue either as the Hostess personality for interviews or as a significant theme in The Golden Notebook.

Saturday, January 18, 2014

Henry James and the “Host Personality”: the Alternate Personality in Multiple Personality (Dissociative Identity) who does Interviews and Socializes

In my post of November 4, 2013, I mentioned Henry James’s short story, “The Private Life.” One of the characters is a writer, but the person who the other characters see in public is not the one who does the actual writing. While the other characters socialize with the writer’s public personality, the writer’s other personality, who actually does the writing, is back in his apartment busy writing.

This is the answer to the mystery of why the writer that the other characters see socially does not really know whether or not he has written certain things that he has promised. They think he is being evasive, but he really doesn’t know, because he is not the one who does the writing.

In this story, the writer’s two personalities are portrayed as two separate people, because that is the convention for how multiple personality is portrayed in ghost stories.

But that is only half the story. There is another character in this short story who is famous for being a brilliant conversationalist. He always knows just the right thing to say. However, it is eventually revealed that this brilliant conversationalist only exists in public, at social gatherings. In private, as only his wife knows, he disappears. In this ghost story, he becomes literally invisible in private.

In Henry James’s short story, both the writer’s public personality and the brilliant conversationalist are what is known in the psychiatric literature on multiple personality as a “host personality.” In multiple personality, there are 1. the regular, or host, personality, and 2. the alternate personalities. These are commonly referred to as the host and the alters.

So James’s short story makes two points about writers. First, writers have multiple personality. Second, when you are interviewing or just speaking to a writer (or anyone) who, unknown to you, has multiple personality, you are often speaking to the host personality, who may be turned off or asleep in private situations, and who may have no direct awareness of the existence or actions of the other personalities.

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Doris Lessing’s The Golden Notebook (the Nobel Prize winner’s best-known novel) is about Multiple Personality, as Indicated by “the shape of the novel” and Different Handwritings

The Golden Notebook [1962] (Perennial Classics, 1999) is six hundred pages of complex literary fiction, but Doris Lessing, herself, gave us the key to what it is about. In her 1971 commentary, now included as an introduction to the novel, she draws our attention, first and foremost, to “the shape of the novel.”

The novel is divided into five sections, separated by four Notebooks (Black, Red, Yellow, and Blue) kept by the central character, Anna Wulf, a novelist. This highly divided structure represents, Lessing says, the “fragmentation” and “compartmentalisation” of identity. Toward the end of the novel, this dividedness reaches a climax of blatant multiple personality in Anna Wulf and Saul Green. But Anna’s “breakdown” remits—and she appears to heal and achieve a greater degree of “unity”—in the “Golden Notebook” and end of the novel.

Lessing says that “the essence of the book, the organization of it, everything in it, says implicitly and explicitly, that we must not divide things off, must not compartmentalise.”

“This theme of ‘breakdown,’” says Lessing, “that sometimes when people ‘crack up’ it is a way of self-healing, of the inner self’s dismissing false dichotomies and divisions, has of course been written about by other people, as well as by me since then. But this is where…I first wrote about it. Here it is rougher, more close to experience…But nobody so much as noticed this central theme, because the book was instantly belittled, by friendly reviewers as well as hostile ones, as being about the sex war…”

However, Lessing, herself, does not fully understand her novel. She makes it sound as though, 1. most of the book does not describe multiple personality, per se, but only a bad habit of compartmentalization, that 2. if you compartmentalize, you run the risk of developing a temporary bout of multiple personality, but that 3. if you realize and decide that you must not compartmentalize, then your split personality may heal, and you can put all that behind you.

But the central character, Anna, who kept the Notebooks, had full-blown multiple personality all along and did not get over it.

The simplest proof that Anna had multiple personality all along is that, according to the novel, her four Notebooks were written in different handwritings. In my post of October 13, 2013, I give a link to a psychiatric journal article that provides objective documentation of 12 cases of multiple personality. One kind of objective documentation was to go back in the person’s life, to years before they ever saw a psychiatrist and before anyone had ever raised the idea of multiple personality, and find things like old diaries in which the person had used several, distinctly different handwritings.

Moreover, as readers of this blog know, multiple personality starts in childhood and it is usually hidden and camouflaged. So, if an adult who was never thought to have multiple personality has an emotional crisis that looks like blatant multiple personality, but then recovers from the crisis and no longer has any obvious alternate personalities, what has really happened is that a person with multiple personality since childhood has had a crisis in which their usually hidden personalities became temporarily overt, but then, after the crisis, the personalities reverted to their usual hiddenness and camouflage.

I recommend The Golden Notebook to readers of this blog, because it has some very realistic descriptions of multiple personality from the perspective of a person who has experienced it. (I don’t know how else Lessing would have known what she knew about it.) And it shows that multiple personality may be present in persons like Lessing who are not mentally ill and who are very high-functioning.

Thursday, January 9, 2014

The Nobel Novelist [Doris Lessing] Spoke of Having Different “Levels”: Is this Common in Multiple Personality?

In yesterday's post, the mystery novelist told of having “several different people, or ‘I’s’ taking part.” In the same interview, she said that it can be “very frightening to write a story…soaked in emotions that you don’t recognize as your own,” emotions which come from a “different level.” Are “different levels” typical of multiple personality? They are. Let me explain.

Whenever I have initially discovered that a person has multiple personality, I usually meet and interview a handful of identities. But, eventually, I will find that this initial group of identities is not the person’s only group of identities. It is only one level, layer, group, realm, etc.

The members of this initial group or level of identities are more or less aware of each other. Most of them don’t have memory gaps when other members of their group are out. However, you find that the person still has some memory gaps, emotions, or behaviors that cannot be accounted for by any of these known identities. Also, when you ask this group of identities if there are any other identities outside of their group, they may tell you that there are rumors of others, or that they have noticed unaccounted for emotions, etc. In short, you will eventually find that there are other levels, layers, groups, or realms of identities.

So, when the Nobel novelist talks of emotions, etc., coming from “different levels,” she is describing a common situation in multiple personality.

Wednesday, January 8, 2014

The Nobel Novelist [Doris Lessing], In an Interview, Describes Multiple Personalities Located at Different “Levels” In Her Mind

On page 60 of the Nobel novelist’s best-known novel (see post of January 1, 2014), the main character, a novelist, says, “I know very well from what level in myself that novel [the novel the character had written] came from.”

The reason I took notice of the above is that the novelist also referred to “level” in an interview conducted two years after her Nobel novel was published, but which did not happen to mention that particular novel.

The interview did describe the one time in the novelist’s life that she had tried mescaline (peyote). What she described about that experience is very relevant to this blog, but only if what she described had general relevance to her thinking, and was not just unique to the drug experience.

Her use of the word “level,” not only in her discussion of the drug experience, but also in her non-drug writing (her novel, quoted above) shows that what she said in the interview revealed something generally true about her mind. To quote from the interview:

“I took one dose [of mescaline] out of curiosity…There were several different people, or ‘I’s’ taking part…Several people were talking and in different voices throughout the process—it took three or four hours—…[including the voice of a] philosophic baby, a creature who argued steadily with God…”

“Yes, but who created all this? Who made it up?”

“It wasn’t me, the normal ‘I' who conducts her life.”

“And of course, this question of I, who am I, what different levels there are inside of us, is very relevant to writing, to the process of creative writing about which we know nothing whatsoever. Every writer feels when he, she, hits a different level. A certain kind of writing or emotion comes from it. But you don’t know who it is who lives there…That is a literary question, a problem to interest writers…”