BASIC CONCEPTS

— When novelists claim they do not invent it, but hear voices and find stories in their head, they are neither joking nor crazy.

— When characters, narrators, or muses have minds of their own and occasionally take over, they are alternate personalities.

— Alternate personalities and memory gaps, but no significant distress or dysfunction, is a normal version of multiple personality.

— normal Multiple Personality Trait (MPT) (core of Multiple Identity Literary Theory), not clinical Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD)

— The normal version of multiple personality is an asset in fiction writing when some alternate personalities are storytellers.

— Multiple personality originates when imaginative children with normal brains have unassuaged trauma as victim or witness.

— Psychiatrists, whose standard mental status exam fails to ask about memory gaps, think they never see multiple personality.

— They need the clue of memory gaps, because alternate personalities don’t acknowledge their presence until their cover is blown.

— In novels, most multiple personality, per se, is unnoticed, unintentional, and reflects the author’s view of ordinary psychology.

— Multiple personality means one person who has more than one identity and memory bank, not psychosis or possession.

— Euphemisms for alternate personalities include parts, pseudonyms, alter egos, doubles, double consciousness, voice or voices.

— Multiple personality trait: 90% of fiction writers; possibly 30% of public.

— Each time you visit, search "name index" or "subject index," choose another name or subject, and search it.

— If you read only recent posts, you miss most of what this site has to offer.

— Share site with friends.

MPD Textbooks: — Frank W. Putnam, MD. Diagnosis and Treatment of Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) (a.k.a. Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), New York, The Guilford Press, 1989. —James G. Friesen, PhD. Uncovering the Mystery of MPD, (includes discussion of demonic possession) Eugene, Oregon, Wipf and Stock Publishers,1997.

Saturday, March 8, 2014

Bakhtin says Dostoevsky created the “polyphonic” novel. But wouldn't that require a “polyphonic” (multiple personality) mind?

In Dostoevsky’s writings “one is dealing not with a single author-artist who wrote novels and stories, but with a number of philosophical statements by several author-thinkers—Raskolnikov, Myshkin, Stavrogin, Ivan Karamazov, the Grand Inquisitor, and others…The character is treated as ideologically authoritative and independent; he is perceived as the author of a fully weighted ideological conception of his own, and not as the object of Dostoevsky’s finalizing artistic vision…” (1).

“Dostoevsky…creates not voiceless slaves…but free people, capable of standing alongside their creator, capable of not agreeing with him and even of rebelling against him.
     A plurality of independent…consciousnesses, a genuine polyphony of fully valid voices is in fact the chief characteristic of Dostoevsky’s novels…” (1).

“Dostoevsky is the creator of the polyphonic novel…[which has] a plurality of equally-valid consciousnesses, each with its own world…” (1).

“Dostoevsky’s world is profoundly personalized. He perceives and represents every thought as the position of a personality…” (1).

Bakhtin doesn’t say how Dostoevsky was able to write the “polyphonic” novel.

1. Bakhtin, Mikhail. Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics. Edited and Translated by Caryl Emerson. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1984.

Friday, March 7, 2014

Fyodor Dostoevsky’s The Double: Post #1, a Conventional View

The Double (1) is a novella about Mr. Golyadkin, who has a nervous breakdown when his identical twin-like “double” discredits and displaces him at work and socially.

In a letter, Dostoevsky referred to The Double as his own “confession” (2). “Like his character…Dostoevsky was subject to ‘hallucinations’ which may very well have included delusions [paranoia? having a double?] similar to Golyadkins’s” (2). The Double involves “the splitting of Golyadkin’s personality and the appearance of the double: the internal process is simply given dramatic reality” (2).

Early critics of the work complained that “Dostoevsky was simply portraying a case of paranoia and mental breakdown with no larger significance than that of a case history…‘madness for the sake of madness’” (2).

In the Diary of a Writer, Dostoevsky acknowledged “that ‘my story was not successful’; but he continued to claim that ‘its idea was clear enough, and I have never contributed anything to literature more serious than this idea’” (2).

“Golyadkin’s double represents the…internal split…Dostoevsky’s first grasp of a character-type that became his hallmark as a writer. Golyadkin is the ancestor of all of Dostoevsky’s great split personalities, who are always confronted with their quasi-doubles or doubles (whether in the form of other ‘real’ characters, or as hallucinations) in the memorable scenes of the great novels…” (2).

“The mature Dostoevsky felt that the discovery of this ‘underground’ type, whose first version is Golyadkin, constituted his greatest contribution to Russian literature…its ultimate source lay in Dostoevsky’s own psychology” (2).

1. Dostoevsky, Fyodor. The Double: Two Versions [1846/1866]. Translated from the Russian by Evelyn Harden. New York, Ardis, 1985.
2. Frank, Joseph. Dostoevsky: The Seeds of Revolt 1821-1849. Princeton University Press, 1976, Volume One [of five], pp. 295-312.

Wednesday, March 5, 2014

William James, Multiple Personality, and The Varieties of Religious Experience: Its Historical and Intellectual Context

In my post of December 26, 2013, I discussed William James’s conclusion that the psychological basis of religious experience was the same as the psychological basis for multiple personality: the mind’s capacity for multiple consciousness (in contrast to the erroneous Freudian psychoanalytic model of the conscious/unconscious).

If you want to know more about it, I recommend Ann Taves, a professor of religious studies who has a special interest in cognitive science:

Taves, Ann: “The Fragmentation of Consciousness and The Varieties of Religious Experience: William James’s Contribution to a Theory of Religion,” Chapter 3, pages 48-72, in William James and a Science of Religions: Reexperiencing The Varieties of Religious Experience, edited by Wayne Proudfoot. New York, Columbia University Press, 2004.

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

The Hoax about when Dostoevsky met Dickens: Why did people believe it?

For some years, serious people believed the hoax that Dostoevsky and Dickens had had a chance encounter in which, Dostoevsky was said to have later reported, Dickens had confided that “There were two people in him, he told me: one who feels as he ought to feel and one who feels the opposite. From the one who feels the opposite I make my evil characters, from the one who feels as a man ought to feel I try to live my life. ‘Only two people?’ I [Dostoevsky] asked.” (For a discussion of the hoax, per se, see Eric Naiman’s “When Dickens met Dostoevsky” in The Times Literary Supplement of 10 April 2013.)

Dostoevsky’s alleged punch line—“Only two people?“—is funny, because, in response to Dickens’s confession of having multiple personality, Dostoevsky, rather than expressing surprise, implies that writers like they are would certainly have more than just two personalities.

People believed the hoax, because they agree with this blog, at least subconsciously.

Monday, March 3, 2014

A Dance or Ritual to Establish Expertise, Not a “Classic Mistake”

In my last post, I called the interviewer’s failure to pursue what was going on between the writer and his characters a “classic mistake,” by which I meant that writers are always saying those kinds of things about how they don’t create their characters, and interviewers never ask more about it.

However “mistake” may be the wrong word, because it implies that the interviewer really wanted to know all about the characters, that the writer really wanted to tell, and that they were both inept.

But people such as the interviewer and writer in this case are not inept. If they didn’t pursue the issue, it’s because they didn’t want to. So they must have had another reason for her question and his answer.

I think that they were using that question and answer as markers of their expertise. The interviewer was showing that she was no amateur who thought that writers create their characters. Her question about how the characters “arrive” (not how they are created) showed that she is a professional.

And the writer was also showing that he is is a professional. Amateur writers create their characters. Professional fiction writers, quoted again and again in this blog, have characters that, somehow, seem to arrive with minds of their own.

If anyone is making a classic mistake, it’s the readers of such interviews who don’t complain that they are not getting the whole story.
An Interview in The Writer’s Chronicle makes the Classic Mistake

The Association of Writers & Writing Programs publishes The Writer’s Chronicle magazine. In the current issue—March/April 2014, pages 14-28—Richard Bausch, an award-winning writer and professor, is interviewed by Sarah Anne Johnson, author of The Art of the Author Interview: And Interviewing Creative People.

The interview includes the following question and answer:
Johnson: How do your characters arrive, in a piece of dialogue, a look, a gesture?
Bausch: It feels like they walk into the sentences I’m fumbling with and make their own space, and refuse to be subject to my will about them. So I let them do what they seem to want to do. Whenever they are the real thing, they surprise me. I don’t know what they’re going to do, and then they do it and I’m surprised without being incredulous. I know this sounds mystical and all that, but I really don’t mean it that way. I’m talking about how it feels.

This question and answer did not follow any discussion of character, and the question after it changes the subject. So what we appear to have is a routine question which assumes (based on the interviewer’s experience) that characters will “arrive” (as opposed to being created), and an answer by the writer that fulfills all the interviewer’s expectations.

Apparently the interviewer is not surprised to hear the writer say that his characters are not consciously created: They just walk in when he’s fumbling around and make their own space; they are not subject to his will, but do what they want to do, and surprise him; and it all appears to the writer to be a sort of mystical experience, in that it seems to be out of his control and to defy rational explanation.

The classic mistake in this interview is its failure to pursue what’s going on with the writer and his characters.

Sunday, March 2, 2014

Hearing Voices: When is it, and when is it not, psychotic?

If a person hears voices, there are three possibilities:

[NOT PSYCHOTIC] No diagnosis or condition. Some people hear a voice at times. If the voice is religious, it is considered normal in that person’s culture. The person knows that other people cannot hear what they hear. Unlike multiple personality, the perceived speaker (if any) is not three-dimensional, is not highly interactive, and is not like a person with their own story. It does not cause distress or dysfunction. 

Psychosis. As in schizophrenia (or any of numerous other psychotic illnesses). Psychosis means an impaired ability to distinguish what is subjective from what is objective. (“Everyone can hear it, or they would, if they had the same computer chip in their brain.”) The main causes and treatments are biological (but psychosocial issues must be addressed, too).

[NOT PSYCHOTIC] Multiple Personality. The voices are the voices of personified psychological beings—they think, therefore they are—with minds of their own. It is not psychotic: Even though it is experienced as very real, the person knows that it is subjective. It is psychological (originating as a way to cope with traumatic experiences in childhood). The alternate identities and their voices are not treatable with medication. It is a diagnosable mental illness only if it causes distress or dysfunction. Otherwise, it is normal, and may be an asset (e.g., to write novels).

Many years ago, when psychiatrists realized that hearing voices did not necessarily mean that a person had schizophrenia (or some other psychosis), Dr. Kurt Schneider proposed that there were certain kinds of voices (and other symptoms) that were seen in psychosis only. These are called “Schneiderian first-rank symptoms.” For example, he said you could be sure that people had psychosis if they heard voices talking among themselves. But he was wrong.

It turns out that this and certain other of his so-called first-rank symptoms are more common in multiple personality than in schizophrenia (Kluft R: First-rank symptoms as a diagnostic clue to multiple personality disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1987;144:293-298.) If someone hears voices conversing, it is less likely to be a person with schizophrenia, and more likely to be a novelist whose characters are talking to each other.

Saturday, March 1, 2014

Why did Freud worry that he, himself, in real life, might have a Double?

Please see the post of November 7, 2013.
Dictionaries of Literary Terms (“the Double”; “Ghost Story”) show Blind Spot for Multiple Personality in Literary Theory

I tried to look up “the Double” in three dictionaries of literary terms, two from England (1,2) and one from the USA (3). The two dictionaries from England had no entry at all for the Double.

The American dictionary defines “Double, the” as “a device whereby a character is self-duplicated (the Doppelganger, ‘mirror image,’ or ‘alter ego’), as in the case of…Conrad’s The Secret Sharer, or divided into two distinct, usually antithetical, personalities, as in Stevenson’s The Strange Case of  Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde…” Other works cited include Wilde’s The Picture of Dorian Gray, Dostoevsky’s The Double, and Virginia Woolf’s Mrs. Dalloway. It says that this literary device represents an interest in the “divided self.” But it makes no mention of, or reference to, multiple personality, per se; none whatsoever.

The two UK dictionaries don’t have an entry for the Double, but they do have for “ghost story” (the American dictionary doesn’t). Indeed, the Penguin entry is encyclopedic: eight pages. It defines a ghost story as “a fictional narrative…in which the spirit of a person…, no longer bound by natural laws…‘haunts’…as a kind of ‘presence’.” Two stories by Robert Louis Stevenson are cited, but not the one about Jekyll and Hyde.

Now, having a “divided self” or experiencing a “presence,” does, at the very least, suggest the possibility, and raise the issue, of multiple personality. But professors of literature, as reflected in dictionaries of literary terms, don’t think of this, because it is not encompassed by any of the literary theories with which they are familiar.

1. Baldick, Chris: The Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2008.
2. Cuddon JA (revised by Preston CE): The Penguin Dictionary of Literary Terms and Literary Theory. London, Penguin Books, 1999.
3. Beckson K, Ganz A: Literary Terms: A Dictionary. New York, Farrar Straus Giroux, 1989.

Friday, February 28, 2014

William Faulkner’s Multiple Personality: Hidden in Plain Sight

In a short story, written by Faulkner and read to his friends as a “joke,” Faulkner’s alter ego says that he, not Faulkner, is the one who does Faulkner’s writing, that he is Faulkner’s ghost writer:

Faulkner, William: “Afternoon of a Cow” (1937/1947). In Uncollected Stories of William Faulkner, edited by Joseph Blotner. New York, Random House, 1979/1997.

For a discussion of that story and related issues, see:

Grimwood, Michael: Heart in Conflict: Faulkner’s Struggles with Vocation. Athens, The University of Georgia Press, 1987.

For most of his life, people noticed that Faulkner had puzzling and inconsistent behaviors and attitudes, but multiple personality, per se, was never considered or identified. Why wasn’t it?

Why is it so common for multiple personality like Faulkner’s to be hidden in plain sight? Partly because multiple personality is naturally and intrinsically secretive and camouflaged. And partly because people have never been told what multiple personality is, and what it is really like: which can be remedied by starting with the June 2013 post and then reading the rest of this blog.

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Multiple Personality is “more real than real,” the brain’s version of modern technology’s Virtual Reality

How you react to the definition of multiple personality in the last post will depend on whether you, yourself, do or don’t have it.

If you don’t have multiple personality, you may believe that normal people can’t and don’t really think that way. You may think that a person could pretend or imagine that they experience the presence of more than one person. But you can’t believe that they truly experience these “people” as being, in Toni Morrison’s words, “much more real than real people.” 

If you do have multiple personality, you may believe that everyone has their own private people, just as you do. But since it’s a private thing, they don’t talk about it, any more than you discuss your private people with them. If you are a novelist, perhaps you have discussed this with other novelists, and since other novelists probably are like you, that only confirmed your belief that everyone, deep down, is the same (although you wouldn’t be surprised if people without artistic sensibility weren't in touch with it).

Morrison’s phrase (quoted above) is a great way of expressing the point that, to people with multiple personality, it’s very real (subjectively), even though a part of their mind is always well aware that it’s not real (objectively).

Multiple personality might be thought of as the brain’s version of modern technology’s virtual reality. You know it’s not real, but it sure seems real, maybe more real than real.

Monday, February 24, 2014

Definition of Multiple Personality (aka Dissociative Identity or Multiple Identity) for Nonpsychiatric Purposes

1. A person has more than one sense of identity or personhood; that is, they have more than one “I”: Ia and Ib (the alternate personality). What gives Ia and Ib their separate senses of identity?

2. Ia and Ib think and act independently and differently. Sometimes Ia is in control. Sometime Ib is in control. For example, they can have a conversation. Sometimes Ia speaks and Ib listens. Sometimes the reverse. They may have different opinions, attitudes, moods, and self-images (as to age, height, sex, etc.).

3. They have separate memory banks. At least one of them will have known and remembered things that the other one hadn't. For example, Ib may tell Ia a story of events that Ia hadn’t known about or remembered. That is, Ia had had amnesia, a memory gap, for the events (real or imagined) that Ib had remembered or imagined.

All the above may be fulfilled when a novelist has a character or another narrator with a mind of its own.

Does Ib, the alternate personality, have to come out and interact with other people? No. It doesn’t have to. Or it may do so rarely. And even if it does so frequently, other people usually don’t realize it, because alternate personalities generally prefer to remain incognito as far as outsiders (people other than Ia) are concerned.

The essential difference between normal multiple personality (which many novelists have) and multiple personality disorder (the mental illness) is that the latter causes the person a significant amount of distress and/or dysfunction. In contrast, some people with normal multiple personality can be very high-functioning, even winning the Nobel Prize.

Sunday, February 23, 2014

Sue Grafton’s Kinsey Millhone Mystery series illustrates the failure of the distinction between Plot-Driven and Character-Driven

What could be more plot-driven than a detective novel? Everything has to be worked out in detail from start to finish, with its clues and red herrings, realistic police and forensic details, etc., so that it meets genre standards. Moreover, in a series like that, Grafton has to keep comprehensive records of every detail from novel to novel so her fans don’t catch her in a mistake.

However, as discussed in previous posts, the writing of Grafton’s novels involves the same character-driven process found in the work of the so-called literary novelists I have discussed. They all involve characters who, 1. as Mark Twain said, were not, in any ordinary sense, created (e.g., Kinsey originally came to Grafton as an “apparition”), 2. are alternate personalities, with minds of their own, and 3. are, to one extent or another, in the driver’s seat.
Plot-Driven vs. Character-Driven: Why “Character-Driven”?

In the how-to-write-a-novel literature, and perhaps in creative writing programs, the distinction is made between novels that are plot-driven and character-driven.

I always assumed this meant that plot-driven novels emphasize what incident happens next, as in a page-turning thriller, while character-driven novels emphasize the characters’ feelings, conflicts, and relationships. The former is goal-oriented, the latter is growth-oriented.

Furthermore, I always assumed this distinction meant that the plot-driven novel was written by first figuring out the plot. Once this was accomplished, characters could be made to order, according to what the plot required. In contrast, the character-driven novel was written by first creating a character—whose feelings, conflicts, and relationships were to evolve—and the events of the plot would be secondary to that. (We know from Mark Twain and other novelists quoted in previous posts that most novelists don't "create" their characters.)

But why the term “character-driven?” Why not “character-oriented,” “character-centered,” “character-motivated,” “character-conflict,” or “character-growth”? Why “driven”?

Because, as discussed in the last two posts, the character is in the driver’s seat. (Which makes the narrator a “back-seat driver.”)
Clarification of Yesterday’s Post, with a Quote from Toni Morrison

When Dickens and Faulkner said that they got most of what they wrote from their characters, you might have thought, “Well, so what? All you are saying is that they imagined that their characters told them these things.”

Well, yes, they did imagine it, but not in the usual sense of imagining. For example, suppose I wanted to decide what to have for lunch. I would imagine various foods and decide which I preferred. In doing that, I would have the subjective sense that “I” was in charge of the process and that “I” was doing the imagining.

But that is not what Dickens and Faulkner said happened in their writing process. Their subjective experience was not that they imagined most of what they wrote, but that the characters did. They experienced the characters as being independent, thinking beings with minds of their own (which is the essence of multiple personality).

Novelists experience their characters as real. How real? As Toni Morrison said (see post of October 26, 2013), “much more real than real people.”

Saturday, February 22, 2014

When novelists such as Dickens and Faulkner talk about their writing process, most professors don’t take them seriously.

Charles Dickens and William Faulkner said that they didn’t invent most of what they wrote. Once their characters came to life, subjectively, they wrote what their characters told them.

But most professors would insist that Dickens and Faulkner were speaking metaphorically or simply joking. After all, they reason, novelists might have their artistic peculiarities, but they are not crazy.

In contrast, when I read Dickens and Faulkner, and they discuss something as important to them as their writing process, I do take them seriously. There are just too many other novelists, for too many years, who have said similar things.

And in my psychiatric opinion, it doesn’t mean that they are crazy. It means that they have a normal, creative, literary type of multiple personality.

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

What kind of person was William Faulkner, according to an investigative reporter and Faulkner scholars?

“He prefers to be an enigma and one can believe that he will always remain one, even to himself, for his inconsistencies pass artistic license. His is not a split personality but rather a fragmented one…He is thoughtful of others, and oblivious to others; he is kind, and he is cruel; he is courtly, and he is cold;…a man of integrity who has contributed to a false legend about himself. Of more serious importance, he is a great writer and a bad writer.” —The Private World of William Faulkner, Robert Coughlin. NY, Harper & Brothers, 1953.

Coughlin is today mainly remembered for his article about Faulkner in Life magazine (expanded in the above-referenced book) to which Faulkner famously responded with outrage in his essay “On Privacy” (1955). To assess the credibility of Coughlin’s view that Faulkner’s personality went beyond being split—that it was fragmented—I looked up Coughlin in Joseph Blotner’s respected biography of Faulkner (1974/1984). Blotner says, “…his description of the man himself was the best ever written.”

“Who is Faulkner?” was one of the main questions asked at a conference in 1997 honoring Faulkner’s centenary (Faulkner at 100: Retrospect and Prospect. Edited by Donald M. Kartiganer and Ann J. Abadie. Jackson, University Press of Mississippi, 2000). The first five pages of the book are remarks by Joseph Blotner. Pages 18-25 are by a professor of English, Noel Polk:

“…Who was William Faulkner? Only in that split, that bifurcation, which becomes a multiplication, can we hope to locate him…[Polk draws our attention to] a little-read piece [by Faulkner] called ‘Afternoon of a Cow,’ putatively written by one Ernest V. Trueblood, who tells us that he has been ‘writing Mr. Faulkner’s novels and short stories for years’…Ernest V. Trueblood is thus the architect of Faulkner’s literary mansion…The Faulkner-Trueblood split is a particularly interesting one, partly because Faulkner had used the Trueblood pseudonym very early in his career…The two Faulkners, the Faulkner Faulkner and the Trueblood Faulkner…lived side by side with each other, in the same household…The two Faulkners didn’t always live in harmony with each other, and perhaps came at times to hold each other in a kind of disdain or even contempt…Thus we have the Faulkner who could write powerful novels of racial injustice in Mississippi coexisting with the Faulkner who would shoot Negroes in the street to defend Mississippi against the United States…; the Faulkner who could write such powerful portraits of family dysfunction and the Faulkner who could tell his own daughter that nobody remembers Shakespeare’s children…”
J. K. Rowling announces Second Novel written by Robert Galbraith, her Pseudonym and Alter Ego, euphemisms for Alternate Personality

When the author of the Harry Potter novels published The Cuckoo’s Calling under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith, but was found out, she explained that she had wanted to see how the book would do without the benefit of her fame. So why, now that everyone knows Robert Galbraith is her pseudonym, is she continuing to use it for a second novel?

Regarding the origin of the name, she explains that “When I was a child, I really wanted to be called Ella Galbraith, I’ve no idea why…the name had a fascination for me.”

Is Robert Galbraith a pseudonym for an alternate personality, Ella Galbraith? Is he Ella Galbraith’s brother? Does Rowling know?

Monday, February 17, 2014

Virginia Woolf is described by Professors as having Multiple Personality sort of issues

Woolf possesses and communicates not a single, but a multiple personality. I do not approach this multiple personality as a pathological condition, that is, as a more public and controlled form of the madness [bipolar disorder, aka manic-depression] that periodically overwhelmed her. I take what many may consider an even more perverse position: I treat her multiple or plural personalities as the highest achievement of her disciplined art.
—Maria DiBattista: Imagining Virginia Woolf. Princeton University Press, 2009

For she had a great variety of selves to call upon, far more than we have been able to find room for, since a biography is considered complete if it merely accounts for six or seven selves, whereas a person may well have as many thousand. —from Woolf’s Orlando
      Orlando’s biographer keeps disassembling and then re-assembling Orlando’s “selves”: a reflection of Virginia Woolf’s sense of her own “great variety of selves.” As she began to develop her ideas for The Waves—of the author as six different voices speaking in solitude—and as at the same time her public, famous self became increasingly established, her life can be seen as a complicated range of performances. Questions about her “selves” filled her mind in the late 1920s. Her battle-cry, “How I interest myself!” was loud in her ears. She knew she had different ways of presenting her own identity. She kept returning to Orlando’s idea of the unstable self.
—Hermione Lee: Virginia Woolf. New York, Alfred A. Knopf, 1997

She has begun to use the name “Miss Jan” rather than “Virginia” to describe what happened to her; it is a name that she continued to use throughout 1897 [age 15; two years after her mother died]. She writes: “It is so windy to day, that Miss Jan is quite afraid of venturing out. The other day her skirt was blown over her head, and she trotted along in a pair of red flannel drawers to the great amusement of the Curate who happened to be coming out of Church.” The retelling of this event is significant for it explicitly conveys the reason why Virginia Woolf became agoraphobic: she was terrified because her bottom had indeed been exposed. And she was afraid that everyone would see it.
—Louise DeSalvo: Virginia Woolf: The Impact of Childhood Sexual Abuse on Her Life and Work. Boston, Beacon Press, 1989

The above quotations from Professors DiBattista, Lee, and DeSalvo raise the possibility that Virginia Woolf—completely separate from, and unrelated to, her bipolar disorder—had multiple personality.

Friday, February 14, 2014

Malcolm Cowley on William Faulkner’s Concern for Privacy and Tolerance for Inconsistency

At a time when Faulkner’s books were mostly out of print, Malcolm Cowley, as editor of The Portable Faulkner (1946), helped to revive Faulkner’s literary career. Cowley discusses his friendship with Faulkner in The Faulkner-Cowley File: Letters and Memories, 1944-1962  (NY, Viking, 1966).

One issue discussed is Faulkner’s famous concern with privacy. For example, when Life magazine asked Cowley to write a story on Faulkner, Faulkner was so upset with this invasion of his privacy that he discouraged his friend, Cowley, from writing it. And so, as Cowley had warned Faulkner, Life then hired someone else, who was not a friend, to write the story.

But Cowley had to write an introduction for The Portable Faulkner, so he still had to write something biographical. And he found that false information had previously been published which exaggerated Faulkner’s military experience. Cowley wanted to correct the record, but Faulkner wanted Cowley to just avoid repeating the false information and to avoid personal information in general. (Perhaps Faulkner had told people different things at different times about his military experience. As Faulkner said in the Paris Review interview, ask him the same personal question on different occasions and you may get different answers.)

Faulkner expressed his attitude this way: “I will want to blue pencil everything which even intimates that something breathing and moving sat behind the typewriter which produced the books.” He also said, “It is my ambition to be, as a private individual, abolished and voided from history, leaving it markless, no refuse save the printed books.” He wanted his epitaph to be: “He made the books and he died.”

At another point, Cowley, commenting on what Faulkner had described in letters about his writing process, said, “Faulkner had often written as if the author, too, were an imagined character.” Note (added Feb. 16): To clarify what is meant here, the "imagined character" was not a character of the story, but was a narrator who was an alternate personality.

So perhaps Faulkner’s concern for privacy was due to his fear people would discover that no single individual called William Faulkner really existed.

Another issue discussed by Cowley was Faulkner’s attitude toward inconsistencies in his writings. In working on The Portable Faulkner, Cowley had found numerous instances in which the same events were discussed in different books or stories, but with glaringly inconsistent details. The most famous example was how Faulkner changed the story of The Sound and the Fury in an Appendix written many years after the book was originally published.

Faulkner wrote to Cowley: “The inconsistencies in the appendix prove that to me the book is still alive after 15 years…it is the book itself which is inconsistent: not the appendix. That is, at the age of 30 I did not know these people [the characters] as at 45 I now do; that I was even wrong now and then in the very conclusions I drew from watching them [he got the story from “watching” the characters]…”

What does Faulkner mean that “the book is inconsistent,” not he? “I listen to the voices [of the characters],” Faulkner told Cowley, “and when I put down what the voices say, it’s right. Sometimes I don’t like what they say, but I don’t change it.” Unless and until the characters or the book tells him something different.